St Johnstone
Dundee UnitedBy Tunde Ogundipe — Football expert covering Premier League, MLS, J1 League, and more
St Johnstone and Dundee United head into this fixture with remarkably similar records over their last five outings, yet the visitors have been more prolific in front of goal and have collected three wins in that stretch. The hosts have been slightly more consistent in terms of results, but their recent run includes both draws and defeats. A key differentiator is Dundee United's away form: they have registered two emphatic victories on the road, but also suffered a heavy 3‑0 loss.
Over their last five matches, St Johnstone have recorded two wins, two draws, and one loss. They have scored five goals and conceded four. The results have been mixed: after a 2‑1 win over Hibernian, they lost 0‑1 to Celtic and drew 1‑1 with Falkirk, before bouncing back with a 1‑0 victory against Aberdeen. At home in this sample, they have one win, one draw, and one defeat, scoring three and conceding three.
In the match against Celtic, the hosts fired 15 shots, nine of which were on target, and posted an expected goals (xG) of 1.83. Despite creating five big chances, they failed to score, missing four of them. Against Falkirk, St Johnstone had 13 shots and an xG of 1.16, but again managed only one goal. Defensively, they allowed Hibernian chances worth 2.39 xGA but conceded just once. At home, St Johnstone can generate danger, but their finishing and defensive reliability remain inconsistent.
Dundee United have three wins, one draw, and one loss in their last five matches. They have scored nine goals and conceded four, and their recent record is stronger than the hosts' in terms of victories. On the road, they beat St Mirren 3‑0 and Kilmarnock 4‑0, but sandwiched between those results was a 0‑3 defeat to Motherwell. In the two away wins, they netted seven goals, while in the loss they failed to score.
Attacking statistics underline the visitors' ability to create chances: against Kilmarnock they had 21 shots, created six big chances, and accumulated 3.47 xG. However, that xG figure was notably lower than the four actual goals, so replicating such clinical finishing is not guaranteed. In the Motherwell match, Dundee United managed only five shots and 0.25 xG, while conceding three goals. Their most recent victory, 1‑0 over Hibernian, was far from straightforward: the opponents created 2.23 xG and registered eight shots on target. The visitors' away run is productive, but their defence does allow opportunities.
In the last five head‑to‑head meetings between these sides, there has been one draw, while Dundee United have won three times. All five encounters saw no more than three goals, and four of them finished with a total of two goals or fewer. In current averages, St Johnstone score 1.75 goals per home game and concede 1.5, while Dundee United score and concede an average of 1.75 on the road. The visitors have won more frequently in recent matches and have been effective away from home, but their heavy wins sit alongside a 3‑0 defeat. This makes Dundee United's advantage in results clear, but questions remain about both teams' defences.
St Johnstone can create chances at home, as shown by their 15 shots and 1.83 xG against Celtic, but they also failed to capitalise on their xG advantage against Falkirk. Dundee United arrive after two big away wins, yet their 3‑0 loss to Motherwell highlights inconsistency. In recent head‑to‑heads, Dundee United have more often come out on top, and over the last five matches they have won more frequently than the hosts. The combination of current form and historical meetings gives the visitors strong arguments, although the likelihood of conceding remains high. The main prediction is Dundee United not to lose. This is based on their three wins in the last five matches and their advantage in the head‑to‑head record, where they have won three of the last five meetings and lost only once.
The editorial prediction is provided for informational purposes only and should not be treated as a direct call to action. Every reader should do their own analysis before deciding on a bet.
The match takes place on 17 October 2026 at 15:00.
The main prediction is Dundee United not to lose, based on their three wins in the last five matches and head-to-head advantage.
Dundee United recorded two emphatic away victories: 3-0 against St Mirren and 4-0 against Kilmarnock, but also suffered a 3-0 loss to Motherwell.
In the last five meetings, Dundee United have won three, there has been one draw, and all five matches had no more than three goals.
St Johnstone have one win, one draw, and one defeat at home in the last five matches overall, scoring three and conceding three.
They had 15 shots and 1.83 xG against Celtic but failed to score, and against Falkirk they had 13 shots and 1.16 xG. Defensively, they allowed Hibernian chances worth 2.39 xGA.